🍽️

Best Restaurants & Dining in Newcomerstown, OH

2 businesses listed · Updated May 15, 2026

Looking for restaurants & dining in Newcomerstown? 2 local businesses have claimed spots on the Newcomerstown community board.

This list is curated from owner-verified $1/month listings on LocalSquare — businesses sign up themselves and update their own information. The Newcomerstown area serves about 7,535 residents with a median household income of $49,188.

Duchess
Duchess
Newcomerstown, OH
Looking for good food in Newcomerstown, OH? Duchess is a neighborhood favorite with consistent quality.
Terry's Pizza Shoppe
Terry's Pizza Shoppe
Newcomerstown, OH
Terry's Pizza Shoppe brings authentic pizza to Newcomerstown, OH with made-from-scratch dough and quality toppings.

Also Near Newcomerstown

Stone CreekPort WashingtonWest LafayetteKimboltonPlainfieldGnadenhutten

Frequently asked questions

How many restaurants & dining businesses are listed in Newcomerstown, OH?

2 owner-verified restaurants & dining businesses are currently listed on this page. New listings appear within minutes of a business claiming its spot on the Newcomerstown board.

How does a business get on this list?

Any restaurants & dining business serving Newcomerstown can claim a spot on the LocalSquare Newcomerstown board for $1/month. Once claimed, it appears on this "Best Restaurants & Dining in Newcomerstown" page and on the main city board.

What ZIP codes does Newcomerstown, OH include?

Newcomerstown is served by ZIP codes 43832. Each ZIP has its own community board where local businesses pin their listings.

How is this list ordered?

Businesses are sorted by Google rating (highest first), then by claim date (longest-listed first). Where a business has imported its Google Business Profile, the live rating and review count are shown.

List your business in Newcomerstown

Your business. On Google. $1 a month.

Claim Your Spot
← Restaurants & Dining in Ohio ← All Restaurants & Dining