🍽️

Best Restaurants & Dining in New Carlisle, OH

3 businesses listed · Updated May 25, 2026

This page tracks 3 restaurants & dining businesses in New Carlisle, OH (ZIPs 45344).

Each business pays $1/month to keep its spot — listings update when owners update them. New restaurants & dining businesses are added to this page as soon as they claim a board spot.

Speedy Cafe
Speedy Cafe
New Carlisle, OH
Known for generous portions and friendly service, Speedy Cafe is a staple restaurant in New Carlisle, OH.
Carmelas Pizzeria
Carmelas Pizzeria
New Carlisle, OH
From classic cheese to specialty pies, Carmelas Pizzeria in New Carlisle, OH keeps locals coming back.
Twist Cupcakery
Twist Cupcakery
New Carlisle, OH
From croissants to custom cakes, Twist Cupcakery in Dayton, OH is a baking destination.

Also Near New Carlisle

MedwayFairbornChristiansburgNorth HamptonEnonDayton

Frequently asked questions

How many restaurants & dining businesses are listed in New Carlisle, OH?

3 owner-verified restaurants & dining businesses are currently listed on this page. New listings appear within minutes of a business claiming its spot on the New Carlisle board.

How does a business get on this list?

Any restaurants & dining business serving New Carlisle can claim a spot on the LocalSquare New Carlisle board for $1/month. Once claimed, it appears on this "Best Restaurants & Dining in New Carlisle" page and on the main city board.

What ZIP codes does New Carlisle, OH include?

New Carlisle is served by ZIP codes 45344. Each ZIP has its own community board where local businesses pin their listings.

How is this list ordered?

Businesses are sorted by Google rating (highest first), then by claim date (longest-listed first). Where a business has imported its Google Business Profile, the live rating and review count are shown.

List your business in New Carlisle

Your business. On Google. $1 a month.

Claim Your Spot
← Restaurants & Dining in Ohio ← All Restaurants & Dining